MUCC & MTPCA File Reply to NRC Briefs

Justin Tomei • December 5, 2024

On November 26, Michigan United Conservation Club (MUCC) and the Michigan Trappers and Predator Callers Association (MTPCA) filed their reply to briefs filed on behalf of the Natural Resources Commission (NRC). 


MUCC’s brief, which can be read HERE, addresses the arguments the NRC made in defense of their decision to close the coyote season from mid-April to mid-July. 

As expected, the commission attempted to re-rationalize the partial season closure. MUCC’s brief highlights the actual rationale as provided by commissioners at the time of the vote. 


The statements from the commissioners clearly show that sound scientific management was not a consideration in the decision-making process. 

MUCC Policy and Government Affairs Manager Justin Tomei said the approach in the commissions brief was not unexpected and shows they did not use science in their decision making. 


“The commission is required by statute to use the best available science,” said Tomei. “The rationale provided by the commission at the time of the vote made it clear, the decision was not based on biological management. The attempt to re-rationalize the partial season closure reemphasizes how their legal charge was not the driving factor behind their decision making.” 


MUCC is joined in the lawsuit by MTPCA who filed a separate brief, found HERE.   


MTPCA’s brief takes a similar position as MUCC’s, highlighting the actual reasons as provided by commissioners, that the coyote season was shortened.   


MTPCA President Joe Velchansky says this issue continues to be bigger than coyotes and is about the future of our scientific natural resource management. 


“This lawsuit and the combined work of MTPCA and MUCC has never just been about coyotes,” Velchansky said. “Scientific management is the bedrock of protecting our natural resources. Emotional pleas and decisions made due to social perceptions or political fear severely undermine that foundation.” 


This is the last set of filings in this lawsuit, now the judge can order oral arguments or rule on the briefs submitted.   

For more information on MUCC visit mucc.org. 


Contact: jtomei@mucc.org 


For more information on MTPCA visit mtpca.com   

Contact: merlejones336@gmail.com 


Recent Posts

March 2025 NRC Recap

By Justin Tomei • March 13, 2025
March 2025 NRC Recap

Leaping into World Frog Day: Blanchard's Cricket Frog

By Olivia Triltsch • March 13, 2025
Blanchard’s cricket frog plays both roles of predator and prey within the ecosystem, influencing other species populations from both sides.

MUCC Celebrates Conservation Leaders at 2025 Annual Awards Banquet

By Tyler Mehigh • March 11, 2025
Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) proudly honored outstanding individuals and organizations for their dedication to preserving Michigan’s natural resources at the 2025 Conservation Awards Banquet. The annual event recognizes those who have demonstrated exceptional leadership, advocacy, and service to conservation. Ron Olson – 50 Years of Service to Conservation Award With a remarkable career spanning five decades, Ron Olson has made a lasting impact on Michigan’s parks and outdoor recreation. As Chief of the Parks and Recreation Division for the Michigan Department of Natural Resources, Olson expanded the state park system, enhanced trail programs, and secured significant funding for infrastructure improvements. His leadership has shaped the future of Michigan’s outdoor spaces for generations to come. Ron Burris – President’s Award A dedicated leader within MUCC, Ron Burris played a pivotal role in restructuring the organization’s governance, ensuring a more effective policy and executive board structure. His efforts in promoting conservation education, community engagement, and safety initiatives—such as increasing AED availability in clubs—have strengthened MUCC’s impact across Michigan. Senator Sam Singh & Representative Graham Filler – Conservation Legislators of the Year Recognized for their bipartisan leadership in securing $1.9 million in funding for the Elsie Dam removal, Senator Singh and Representative Filler have demonstrated a commitment to conservation and ecological restoration. Their advocacy ensures the protection of Michigan’s waterways, fish habitats, and public safety. Grand Valley Cap N Ballers – Affiliate of the Year With a long-standing tradition of promoting historical shooting sports and conservation, Grand Valley Cap N Ballers (GVCNB) has been a key supporter of MUCC’s mission. Hosting major regional events and fundraisers, GVCNB has played a crucial role in supporting MUCC’s conservation efforts while preserving Michigan’s outdoor heritage. Mike Avery – Conservation Communicator of the Year A leading voice in outdoor media, Mike Avery has dedicated his career to educating and inspiring Michigan’s outdoor enthusiasts through his popular radio show and podcast, Mike Avery’s Outdoor Magazine. By spotlighting conservation leaders and critical environmental issues, Avery has significantly contributed to public awareness and advocacy for Michigan’s natural resources. MUCC extends its heartfelt congratulations to all award recipients for their outstanding contributions to conservation. Their dedication ensures that Michigan’s natural heritage remains protected for future generations. For more information on MUCC’s conservation efforts, visit mucc.org .
More Posts
Share by: