Public comment regarding Camp Grayling expansion on state-owned lands needed

lschultz • August 8, 2022

With no specific deadline for public comment regarding the proposed expansion of the National Guard base, those interested should submit comments sooner rather than later.

In June, the National Guard announced its intention to expand Camp Grayling’s current lease of 148,000 acres to 315,000 acres — more than doubling its current footprint on public land. For the guard to do so, it must receive sign-off from Department of Natural Resources (DNR) Director Dan Eichinger and go through a thorough and intense review process first.

The DNR manages the state-owned lands in question for Michiganders to hunt, fish, trap, and recreate on. The proposed area for expansion contains lakes, rivers, streams, forests and fields that are utilized by a variety of wildlife and recreationists.

Understanding why the military needs this amount of additional land is a concern for Michigan United Conservation Clubs, said policy assistant Justin Tomei.

“To date, MUCC and those questioning this expansion have received minimal substantive feedback on why this is a necessary expansion,” Tomei said. “MUCC supports freedom, but it is not an acceptable answer in this context. Proving the need for an expansion falls squarely on the shoulders of the guard.”

MUCC opposes the expansion of Camp Grayling except in a national emergency, per a 1989 resolution (click here to read).

The proposal and review come first

The director must first initiate a review for the DNR to move forward with determining what impacts the proposed expansion would have.

DNR Forest Division Supervisor Tom Barnes, who oversees the region Camp Grayling’s lease currently falls within, said if a review of this magnitude were to be initiated, it would likely be his team that undertakes part of it.

“The resources that would be required of my staff to undertake this proposal are still to be determined,” Barnes said. “We would likely need to contact neighboring units and ask their staff also to start looking into the review process.”

Barnes said this work would be additive to his staff’s regular duties.

T he department released an interactive public input map (click here) and a press release regarding the proposed lease expansion of the base and what state lands would be impacted in June.

The review process would consider what lands are eligible for the expansion. Lands purchased using Pittman-Robertson funds (federal excise taxes from firearms, ammo and archery equipment allocated to the state based on hunting license sales) would be excluded. 

MUCC’s primary concern at this stage is the resource drain that will be expended to undertake a review of this magnitude with no compensation from the federal government or military, Tomei said.

“The DNR review process will take at least a year,” Tomei said. “We are learning that there will be no financial compensation to the department for this year of review and shifted staff priorities. What won’t get done if this proposal is initiated? That is a big question for us right now.”

At public meetings, the base has committed to ensuring no activities or expansion would be within 1,500 feet of a waterbody.

What if it is approved?

Another MUCC concern is the additional impact on the land and wildlife as an unnecessary burden to the department and constituents who utilize, manage and protect it. 

According to an FAQ document released by the National Guard, “low impact or light maneuver training consists of foot traffic, tents, bivouacking and port-a-johns. Vehicle travel will be restricted to current state forest roads and trails.”

While considered light impact by the National Guard, there is a distinct difference between state lands and roadways currently utilized by military personnel from Camp Grayling and those not in terms of habitat and road degradation. 

“MUCC feels that this lease expansion or proposal does not align with the DNR’s mission statement , our organization’s core values and does not represent a risk we feel is acceptable for the waters, wildlife and access Michiganders cherish,” Tomei said. 

Lastly, the department is ordered to keep open state hunting land via an amended 2009 statute unless certain circumstances are met. 

Public Act 47 of 2009, introduced by Rep. Judy Nerat (D-Menominee) and signed into law by Gov. Jennifer Granholm, states: “2(a) Keep land under its control open to hunting unless the department determines that the land should be closed to hunting because of public safety, fish or wildlife management, or homeland security concerns or as otherwise required by law. 2(b) Manage land under its control to support and promote hunting and fishing opportunities to the extent authorized by law.”

The National Guard has said that lands will not be closed; however, the proposal only commits to specifically keeping land open during firearm deer season. If the intent is not to close any public land, that should be reflected in the proposal language.

Anyone wishing to submit public comment on the plan can visit the state’s webpage.

Join Michigan United Conservation Clubs to help protect your access to public lands and protect your rights to hunt, fish, trap and shoot: http://bit.ly/JoinMUCC

Recent Posts

By Justin Tomei October 7, 2025
The Michigan Natural Resources Commission (NRC) will convene for its October meeting on Thursday, October 9, 2025, at Michigan Technological University’s Rozsa Center for the Performing Arts in Houghton, MI. This monthly gathering brings together commissioners, Michigan Department of Natural Resources (DNR) staff, and the public to discuss policy decisions and updates impacting the state’s natural resources, wildlife, and outdoor recreation opportunities. The meeting will begin with Coffee with Commissioners from 8:30 to 9:30 a.m., followed by the formal session at 9:30 a.m. Attendees can park for free in Lot 10, located east of the Rozsa Center. The meeting will open with a presentation from DNR leadership, including several notable updates and informational reports: Spring Turkey Regulations: Wildlife Division staff will present proposed changes to spring turkey hunting regulations for 2026. Wildlife Habitat Grants : Program leads will outline new habitat grant initiatives and highlight ongoing restoration efforts across the state. Moose Population Monitoring: A presentation will cover results from the most recent moose survey and discuss ecological and environmental factors limiting population growth. White-Nose Syndrome: The Wildlife Division will provide the latest data on the spread and impact of white-nose syndrome on Michigan’s bat populations. New Business The commission will consider a range of new proposals and action items, including: Oil and Gas Lease Auction: Approval for a proposed October 21, 2025, lease auction for energy development on state-managed lands. Land Transactions: Consideration of multiple land sales, acquisitions, and donations, including parcels in Tuscola, Wayne, St. Clair, and Luce counties. Wildlife Orders: Review of spring turkey regulations for the 2026 hunting season . Old Business The NRC will also revisit several regulatory items from previous meetings, including proposed amendments to a number of Fisheries Orders. This includes an amendment further expanding underwater spearfishing to larger portions of the Great Lakes. All orders and amendments for consideration can be found at the NRC agenda, HERE .
By Justin Tomei October 3, 2025
Early Friday, morning, the Michigan Legislature approved a budget for the 2026 fiscal year. The two chambers and the governor agreed to a deal earlier this week and passed a stopgap to keep the state government open while work on the omnibus bill was finalized. The DNR budget is highlighted by some minor cuts, and new boilerplate language: No license fee increases were included No recreation passport opt-out was included Nature awaits program was removed as an on-going program Reduces 4.0 FTE positions for Fish Production and 15.0 FTE positions for Fisheries Resource Management Reduces 20.0 FTE positions and $200,000 for Wildlife Management Reduces invasive species prevention and control by $1.2 million Appropriates $2.8 million GF/GP (one-time) for fish production and stocking in Great Lakes and inland fisheries Reduces wetland restoration, enhancement, and acquisition funding by $1 million. In-person work prioritization New DNR scorecard and reporting requirements Prohibition on utility scale solar and wind projects on public lands An authorization to increase restricted fund appropriations if a license fee bill is passed The House Fiscal Analysis of the budget can be found HERE . To ensure our natural resources remain protected and managed thoughtfully, and our outdoor heritage defended, join Michigan United Conservation Clubs today: http://bit.ly/JoinMUCC .
By Olivia Triltsch October 2, 2025
History
More Posts