Conservation organization files suit against resources commission

Justin Tomei • March 28, 2024

On March 28, the nation’s largest statewide conservation organization filed suit against the Natural Resources Commission (NRC), challenging the three-month closure of the coyote hunting season.

At the March NRC, the commission, in a 4-2 vote, voted to close the coyote hunting season from April 16 through July 14 through the adoption of Wildlife Conservation Order #1 of 2024. Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) testified in opposition to the closure.

MUCC filed in Ingham County, arguing that the commission unlawfully closed Michigan’s coyote season, violating their responsibility and legal charge. The Michigan Trappers and Predator Callers (MTPCA) has also filed a lawsuit against the commission in Mackinac County.

The groups argue that the NRC relied on unsubstantiated claims of negative public perception and perceived potential loss of management control, said MUCC Chief Executive Officer Amy Trotter.

“The record is unambiguous: the commission has not heard or cited any scientific literature or rationale justifying the closure,” Trotter said. “Meanwhile, there were hours of public testimony on the practical benefits of coyote hunting during the spring season, while being reinforced with cited literature.”

MUCC’s mission is to unite citizens to conserve, protect, and enhance Michigan’s outdoor heritage, and this issue is bigger than coyote hunting, said MUCC President Rob Miller.

“The board voted unanimously to take this action, consistent with MUCC’s mission,” Miller said. “MUCC was founded on the belief that game management decisions should be grounded in science and insulated from political and social pressures. This is a foundational issue for our organization, and we were obligated to act on behalf of Michigan’s conservationists.”

Mark Spencer, president of the MTPCA, said the idea that trappers and predator callers are behind the closure is misguided.

“The stance taken with litigation clearly shows the trappers and predator callers of Michigan are firmly united behind the principles of science-based management,” Spencer said. “Our groups present a united front to ensure our outdoor heritage is protected and grounded in science for generations to come.”

MUCC’s notice, filed in Ingham County Circuit Court, will be followed by the organization’s briefs. The process is expected to play out over the coming months and MUCC can not waver on its principles, said Trotter.

“MUCC is the nation’s largest, most successful, statewide conservation organization,” said Trotter. “We were founded for moments like this, and we will continue our work to conserve, protect, and enhance Michigan’s natural resources and outdoor heritage.”

To learn more about MUCC and our work, visit www.mucc.org . 

Recent Posts

NRC Commits to Reopening Year-Round Coyote Season

By Justin Tomei • August 15, 2025
Yesterday, the Natural Resources Commission unanimously voted via a formal resolution to reinstate Michigan’s year-round coyote hunting season ahead of the April 2026 closing of the season. This decision represents a win for Michigan’s hunters, and more importantly, sound scientific management. No changes to the wildlife conservation order (WCO) yet, but the commission approved a resolution that stated: “the Michigan Natural Resources Commission is committed to enacting a regulation for Michigan citizens to take coyotes year-round on public and private land through a combination of hunting, trapping, and lethal take of nuisance and damaging animals; and that the Michigan Natural Resources Commission is committed to acting on this matter before next regular furbearer regulation cycle in the Wildlife Conservation Order in 2026.” The vote comes after a year of work by Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) and Michigan Trappers and Predator Callers Association (MTPCA), who filed a lawsuit when the commission illegally closed part of the season in March of 2024. Today's vote constitutes a win for scientific management and Proposal G, but the responsibility to hold the commission to their word is now on all conservationists according to MUCC CEO Amy Trotter. “We all obviously would have preferred a resolution to the issue today,” said Trotter. “The commission has made clear to the conservationists of Michigan that they will fix the 2024 commission’s error, and the responsibility now rests with all of us to hold them to their word.” According to MTPCA President Joe Velchansky, this is a win, but not the final one. “We are closer to righting this wrong today than we were yesterday,” said Velchansky. “We will continue to work with the commission to ensure the commission makes the best decision for the resource, scientific management, and our outdoor heritage.” In February and March of 2024, the NRC, at the request of a small minority of stakeholder groups, approved an order to partially close Michigan’s coyote hunting season from April 15-July 15. The justification for the order was not biological data, or management need. Rather the commission followed emotional pleas and social perceptions, without any objective data backing up the claims, and illegally partially closed coyote season for a quarter of the year. Despite a DNR biologist's statement that the closure was put forward based on perceived social pressures, and countless pages of scientific literature being presented justifying a year-round hunting season, the season was closed. After the meeting, MUCC and MTPCA jumped into action on behalf of sound scientific management and Michigan’s hunters, anglers and trappers. A lawsuit was filed to appeal the decision and after months of trading paperwork, the final briefs were filed in November of 2024. In June of this year, a Lansing Circuit Court Judge ruled that the commission followed their charge in their decision making. Since the March 2024 vote, there has been significant turnover on the commission with four new members currently seated. Commissioner John Walters, who voted no on the closure in 2024, requested the amendment to reopen the season at the February 2025 meeting, and the order was up for information in March and delayed due to commissioner absences and bureaucratic hurdles before today’s vote. Year-round coyote hunting had been in place since the NRC adopted the measure in 2016, when Michigan joined at least 35 other states in allowing for year-round opportunity.  To learn more about MUCC visit MUCC.org To learn more about MTPCA visit MTPCA.com Contact: MUCC: Jtomei@Mucc.org MTPCA: Merlejones336@gmail.com

On the Ground: Storm Damage Relief in Oscoda County

By Olivia Triltsch • August 14, 2025
On Saturday, August 9, 2025, MUCC's OTG program partnered with the Michigan DNR and the Ruffed Grouse Society for a trail clearing project in Oscoda County.

OTG Volunteers Needed: Pigeon River Country State Forest and McMahon Lake Preserve

By Emily VanderWall • August 11, 2025
MUCC will be On The Ground in Pigeon River Country State Forest and Pine Stump Junction this September to improve elk and bat habitats.
More Posts