Proposed Regulations Reveal NRC Transparency Issues

lschultz • July 14, 2020

A slough of amendments were proposed to deer regulations at the June Natural Resources Commission (NRC) meeting and could pass without a thorough vetting.

With three new commissioners joining the NRC in July and regulations impacting 600,000 Michigan hunters on the table, we deserve greater transparency. 

As of right now, amendments could be made to Wildlife Conservation Order (WCO) No. 6 of 2020 pertaining to deer regulations at the NRC meeting next week, pass and appear in the fall hunting digest without being made public prior to the meeting in which they are voted on. These regulations include major changes such as altering long-standing antler point restrictions and changing baiting rules for special hunts. 

This process where amendments could be made without public input is troubling, said Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) Executive Director Amy Trotter. On Thursday, Trotter sent a letter to all seven members of the NRC and DNR Director Dan Eichinger to initiate a conversation on this topic and ask for action before this month’s meeting. 

“While commissioners offered a number of potential changes to deer regulations, only one was included in the updated order,” Trotter said. “This is bad for Michigan deer hunters, but it is even worse for the NRC process. When amendments are presented and acted upon in the eleventh hour, and the public is unsure of whether these changes are backed by data, trust in this process wanes. Things like this make it even more important for MUCC to be the eyes and ears of our members at the NRC. ”

MUCC is committed to working with the DNR and NRC to provide transparency for hunters and anglers in the rule-making process. The management of game and fish in Michigan has been greatly improved by additions and amendments to the Natural Resources Environmental Protection Act – especially Proposal G of 1996 and a few distinct iterations of the Scientific Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act. However, recent hiccups in this process and virtual meetings due to COVID-19 shed light on much-needed improvements for added transparency.

Many of these improvements could come through administrative actions taken by the NRC or DNR staff, including publishing draft meeting minutes, improving citation protocol in WCO memos and creating a formal motion process for planned amendments prior to public comment. 

At the June 2020 NRC meeting, three commissioners proposed amendments to the DNR recommendations for the Wildlife Conservation Order (WCO) Amendment No. 6 of 2020 (deer regulations). 

As MUCC understands the situation, these three commissioners all requested to receive feedback from the department and incorporate possible changes to the WCO before acting on these amendments in July. While one of these changes was made via a formal motion and was incorporated into the July meeting agenda (removing hunter orange requirements on occupied ground blinds; Nyberg), a number of changes were requested verbally by commissioners Tracy and Creagh and were not incorporated into the WCO memo for public review, scrutiny and comment. 

Importantly, it is a very real possibility that these suggestions could be acted upon at next week’s meeting without formal review by the department or the chance for members of the public to weigh in. If the department does weigh in this week, stakeholders will not have the chance to review that analysis before the day of the NRC meeting. 

The traditional NRC process has been that regulations are brought forward, at the very least, for information one month and then taken up as action the following month. This allows public discourse on these issues for between 30 and 45 days, from the publication of the first agenda to a final vote. If the proposed amendments by Creagh and Tracy are passed, they will have never been written or formally presented to the public by the DNR or the NRC prior to July’s meeting – a clear violation of public trust and a blindsided blow to hunters. 

While a citizen could listen to a recording of the meeting to find these amendments, it is MUCC’s understanding that they are only compiled in writing within our own internal report on the June NRC meeting. As noted in the letter, MUCC believes the state has an obligation to provide these amendments to its citizens in writing and provide complete documentation for their action. 

It is critical for outdoorspeople to participate in this process by watching and providing public comments at the NRC.  

**After receiving MUCC’s letter, DNR Staff posted the draft minutes of the June NRC meeting within the July meeting agenda. This is now available for public review. 

Recent Posts

May 2025 NRC Recap

By Justin Tomei • May 8, 2025
The Natural Resources Commission (NRC) met for their May meeting today at Lansing Community College West Campus. The commission voted to return antlered opportunities to the Independence and Liberty hunts at the May Natural Resources Commission meeting. The amendment to restore this opportunity passed after Commissioner Walters withdrew his amendment from April to only partially restore antlered opportunity during these hunts. MUCC testified for the complete restoration of antlered opportunity during these two hunts, per a member passed policy from our 2025 Annual Convention. The commission also voted on, and ultimately accepted, a proposal to allow archery antlerless take in the high snowfall zone in the Upper Peninsula. Additionally, the commission also chose to leave on the table and postpone indefinitely the order to reopen the illegally partially closed coyote season. This prevents the order from dying after today's meeting and makes it eligible for action at a later date. This amendment will remain postponed until the June meeting at the earliest.  MUCC has created the Coyote Coalition to assist in unifying the voice of conservationists in support of Proposal G. To join the Coyote Coalition, visit https://www.mucc.org/coyotecoalition . The commission did adopt proposed fall turkey regulations unanimously. The June commission meeting is Thursday, June 12 in Bay City. To ensure our natural resources remain protected and managed thoughtfully and our outdoor heritage defended, join Michigan United Conservation Clubs today: http://bit.ly/JoinMUCC .

On The Ground: Volunteers at the Annual Jack Pine Planting Day

By Olivia Triltsch • May 8, 2025
In total, volunteers improved about 6 acres of habitat and planted around 6,000 trees in this stand to continue regeneration.

On the Ground Junior: Spring Event Recap

By Katelyn Helsel • May 7, 2025
Our student volunteers have been hard at work improving wildlife habitat on public lands! MUCC’s On the Ground Junior (OTG Jr.) program, a subset of the On the Ground program, is a fully funded field trip program that brings grade-school classrooms into the outdoors to improve fish and wildlife habitat in their local communities. Through activities like native plantings, brush pile building, and invasive species removal, students gain hands-on experience with conservation and positively impact the world around them. Students also participate in educational activities like predator-prey tag to teach them about population dynamics and other natural resources concepts. So far this spring season, MUCC welcomed 69 students, teachers, and chaperones who participated in multiple OTG Jr projects with more on the way! In total, they improved over 12 acres of wildlife habitat. Read on for a recap of each OTG Jr project and see what all our awesome student volunteers have been up to. 
More Posts