A Monarch Kerfuffle, Implications of an ESA Listing

Justin Tomei • July 26, 2022

Last week, an article headlined “Monarch butterflies now classified as endangered” set conservation social media on fire.

Problem is it was (mostly) clickbait.

The monarch butterfly has not been listed as an endangered species under the endangered species act (ESA), and as such they do not receive the legal ESA protections that go with it.

As far as the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) is concerned, monarch butterflies are classified as a candidate for listing

The article is actually about the The International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) listing monarchs as endangered. According to their website:

“Created in 1948, IUCN is now the world’s largest and most diverse environmental network, harnessing the knowledge, resources and reach of our more than 1,400 member organizations and 15,000 experts. This diversity and expertise makes IUCN the global authority on the status of the natural world and the measures needed to safeguard it.”

The IUCN’s endangered species list, or red list as they call it, carries no legal or administrative weight. The list serves as a call to action for governmental actors and regulatory agencies. 

While the decline of monarchs is absolutely concerning, the lesson here is that there is always more to a story than a headline.

A listing as federally endangered, as according to the ESA, brings with it a series of problems that we have seen with countless other species, some even in Michigan.

The largest and most glaring issue is how species become delisted once they are listed. Currently, there is no effective tool or process to delist a species regardless of whether or not the species is recovered. Species tend to stay on the list indefinitely through bureaucratic technicalities, improper listing criteria in the first place, perpetual litigation or some combination of the three. 

A second problem is the unknown complications a monarch listing would have to farmers, developers or anyone else working near monarch habitat. If a milkweed pops up in a field, does all work have to stop to ensure there is not a caterpillar on it? A plan to manage a federally listed monarch butterfly could be exceptionally complicated.

But the neat thing about monarchs is that YOU can help create new monarch habitat at your own home. Monarch Joint Venture has resources and information you can use to create habitat for monarchs and other pollinators. 

You can also get involved in the protection of monarchs and other threatened non-game species by calling your federal legislators urging them to support the Recovering America’s Wildlife Act (RAWA). RAWA has the chance to be a generational piece of conservation funding on the same level as Pittman-Robertson and Dingell-Johnson. RAWA has passed the United States House of Representatives and is now awaiting a vote in the United States Senate.

MUCC will continue to search avenues to modernize the ESA and provide a legal framework for species to gain a durable delisting. 

To ensure our natural resources remain protected and managed thoughtfully in perpetuity, join Michigan United Conservation Clubs today: http://bit.ly/JoinMUCC

 

Recent Posts

By Olivia Triltsch July 3, 2025
The United States is not shy about using big, beautiful fireworks in celebration of many occasions. July 4th is a day of celebration for many within the country, celebrating the country’s independence from Great Britain in 1776. Fireworks and barbecues are the most common modes of celebration on this day in recognition of the historic significance of the day. While these grand displays are something many look forward to each year, it is important to consider the impacts these explosions have on the surrounding area, including pets and wildlife.
By Justin Tomei June 30, 2025
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE MUCC Submits Public Comment in Support of Line 5 Tunnel Project Lansing, MI — Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC), the nation’s largest statewide conservation organization, has submitted formal public comments urging the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to approve the Enbridge Line 5 Tunnel Project. In a letter submitted today, MUCC emphasized the need to move this critical infrastructure forward to protect the Great Lakes while maintaining safe, reliable energy transportation. “MUCC supports the tunnel project as the best available alternative to reduce the risk of an environmental disaster in the Straits of Mackinac while continuing to deliver essential energy products to Michigan families and industries,” said Amy Trotter, CEO of MUCC. “We believe the tunnel project strikes a balance between protecting the environment and maintaining energy security.” MUCC’s position is backed by a formal resolution passed by its membership, which includes thousands of hunters, anglers, trappers, and outdoor enthusiasts across Michigan. The resolution supports the tunnel as a long-term solution that replaces the aging and exposed pipeline segment currently crossing the Straits, offering greater environmental safeguards through secondary containment. The organization cited the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), which acknowledges the tunnel’s benefits, including reduced spill risk and a controlled, buried environment for transporting light crude oil and natural gas liquids. MUCC also rejected the "no action alternative," which would allow the existing line to remain in operation without any new protective infrastructure. “Other alternatives, like transporting fuel by truck or rail, are inefficient and carry greater environmental and safety risks,” Trotter added. “Allowing the current line to operate exposed on the lakebed indefinitely is simply not acceptable.” MUCC’s comment stresses that the organization is not weighing in on the type of energy transported, but rather on the environmental risks and safety benefits of the tunnel itself. Originally approved by the Michigan legislature and governor in 2018, the Great Lakes Tunnel Project represents a once-in-a-generation investment in infrastructure and environmental protection. MUCC urges the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to issue the necessary permits and move forward with construction without further delay. For Media Contact: Justin Tomei jtomei@mucc.org 517-346-6488 #####
By Olivia Triltsch June 26, 2025
Since its inception, MUCC has made great strides in the conservation of natural resources through advocacy, habitat, youth education, and communications.
More Posts