September NRC Meeting: Commissioners pass a handful of fisheries, propose amendments to others for Oct. meeting

lschultz • September 20, 2021

The Natural Resources Commission (NRC) met last Thursday and passed four fisheries orders while tabling several other orders and requesting amendment drafts from the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (DNR).

The fisheries orders that were passed by the commission (with no amendments or changes made) include the following:

DNR Director Daniel Eichigner’s report to the NRC included an introduction of the DNR Wildlife Chief Jared Duquette, a hire from last fall, and having fisheries division staff present on the myriad of fisheries orders that are before the commission — both new business and old. 

Comments from members of the public varied from CWD testing, underwater spearfishing and the budget of the DNR. Director Eichinger mentioned that once the FY 22-23 budget is approved there will be a presentation on it to the commission from department staff. The Director indicated his intent to sign all 5 land transactions that were up for action.

 

New Business

Little discussion was had on the four fisheries orders that were up for new business before the NRC, aside from a commissioner requesting clarification of the Manistique River in FO 210.22 – Designated Trout Streams for Michigan . The clarification would remove the trout stream designation from Devils Creek and its tributaries in Menominee County because the habitat is no longer suitable for trout.

The other fisheries orders that were new business and are available for action at the October meeting included:

 

Old Business

Director Eichinger indicated that he intends to sign the land-use order that would restrict access to water from DNR Parks and Recreation division managed beaches. MUCC covered the matter extensively when it was introduced.

Several fisheries orders that were available for action at the September meeting had amendments proposed by commissioners, which are listed underneath the applicable fisheries order. These amendments will be up for consideration at the October 14 meeting.

Commissioner Richardson proposed an amendment regarding the minimum size limit for walleye. Currently, the minimum size limit for walleye is 15 inches; however, anglers may possess two (2) walleye from 13 to 15 inches as part of the daily possession limit of five walleye. Richardson proposed the removal of the possession of two walleye from 13 to 15 inches and set the minimum size limit for walleye at 15 with a daily possession limit of five walleye.

Commissioner Baird proposed an amendment to add a three-year sunset to the underwater spearfishing regulations.

Commissioner Richardson proposed that department staff draft an amendment for public posting and consideration at the October 14, 2021 meeting, to remove Lake Superior from waters open to underwater spearfishing.

Carol Rose proposed an amendment to delay the ability to harvest northern pike using underwater spear, with season dates of July 1 to March 15th.

Commissioner Richardson proposed an amendment regarding the daily possession limit for round whitefish, otherwise known as Menominee. 

Richardson proposed that the combined daily possession limit for the three species be expanded to allow for an additional 10 Round Whitefish per day on Lake Superior waters only. This proposal would retain the Lake Whitefish and Cisco protections with the 10 fish per day, in combination, but allow for the desired additional harvest opportunities for Round Whitefish in Lake Superior.

 

NRC Subcommittee Discussion

A discussion on subcommittees of the NRC occurred. The recent format, partially due to moving toward a virtual format due to COVID-19, has restricted the ability for active participation of policy subcommittees of the NRC.

This link has more information on the recommendation from Commissioners Baird and Cozad to return to three standing committees, with the option for ad-hoc committees as certain issues present themselves. The three committees that are proposed include the governance committee, fisheries committee and wildlife committee. 

“The purpose of the committees is to identify issues, liaise with DNR staff, arrange for input from independent experts and stakeholders, review scientific literature and data, review regulatory issues within the jurisdiction of the NRC, and ensure that principles of sound scientific management are used in the NRC’s decisionmaking process and advisory role,” according to the above-linked document from the DNR.

NRC Commissioner Keith Creagh mentioned his intent to have the issue of deer tracking with hounds be discussed further by the commission, whether it occurs via an ad-hoc committee or before the commission of the whole.

Currently, deer trackers must have their dogs on a lead while tracking and are unable to dispatch a deer when the hunter is behind or unavailable. MUCC has member-passed policy from 2019 that supports the tracking of deer with dogs off-lead and the dispatch of a deer by the tracker if: the licensed hunter is unable to walk through a dense wooded area or unable to walk due to a temporary or permanent disability or medical condition or the life or safety of the tracking dog is in jeopardy.

The commission met for a closed session at the end of the meeting. The next meeting of the NRC is Oct. 14 at the MSU vet diagnostic center.

Recent Posts

By Justin Tomei May 8, 2025
The Natural Resources Commission (NRC) met for their May meeting today at Lansing Community College West Campus. The commission voted to return antlered opportunities to the Independence and Liberty hunts at the May Natural Resources Commission meeting. The amendment to restore this opportunity passed after Commissioner Walters withdrew his amendment from April to only partially restore antlered opportunity during these hunts. MUCC testified for the complete restoration of antlered opportunity during these two hunts, per a member passed policy from our 2025 Annual Convention. The commission also voted on, and ultimately accepted, a proposal to allow archery antlerless take in the high snowfall zone in the Upper Peninsula. Additionally, the commission also chose to leave on the table and postpone indefinitely the order to reopen the illegally partially closed coyote season. This prevents the order from dying after today's meeting and makes it eligible for action at a later date. This amendment will remain postponed until the June meeting at the earliest.  MUCC has created the Coyote Coalition to assist in unifying the voice of conservationists in support of Proposal G. To join the Coyote Coalition, visit https://www.mucc.org/coyotecoalition . The commission did adopt proposed fall turkey regulations unanimously. The June commission meeting is Thursday, June 12 in Bay City. To ensure our natural resources remain protected and managed thoughtfully and our outdoor heritage defended, join Michigan United Conservation Clubs today: http://bit.ly/JoinMUCC .
By Olivia Triltsch May 8, 2025
In total, volunteers improved about 6 acres of habitat and planted around 6,000 trees in this stand to continue regeneration.
By Katelyn Helsel May 7, 2025
Our student volunteers have been hard at work improving wildlife habitat on public lands! MUCC’s On the Ground Junior (OTG Jr.) program, a subset of the On the Ground program, is a fully funded field trip program that brings grade-school classrooms into the outdoors to improve fish and wildlife habitat in their local communities. Through activities like native plantings, brush pile building, and invasive species removal, students gain hands-on experience with conservation and positively impact the world around them. Students also participate in educational activities like predator-prey tag to teach them about population dynamics and other natural resources concepts. So far this spring season, MUCC welcomed 69 students, teachers, and chaperones who participated in multiple OTG Jr projects with more on the way! In total, they improved over 12 acres of wildlife habitat. Read on for a recap of each OTG Jr project and see what all our awesome student volunteers have been up to. 
More Posts